Boxpressd Cigar App
  • Feed
  • Virtual Humidor
  • Journal
  • Cigar Discovery
  • Shop
  • Today's Deals
  • Local Pickup
  • Shop All
  • Nearby
  • Lounges & Shops
  • Upcoming Events
  • Social
  • Nubs
  • Saved Lists
  • Friends
  • Virtual Lounge
  • Groups
  • Help & Support
  • Contact
  • Cigar 101
  • Get Help
  • Request Feature

Montecristo
New York Connoisseur Edition

Average User Rating
87
AppearanceDrawBurnFlavor
Average Rating Based On 18 Ratings

Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition reviews & smoke sessions

James T. Patterson
James T. Patterson
Smoked May 31
Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition
8718
87
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Consistent review, now having 2.5 years of rest. The profile is full of chocolate, coffee, and a light mix of pepper & spice. Some nuttiness appeared with the coffee pairing. Flavors stayed true without any bitterness, allowing the rich tobacco to pull through. The draw was smooth and open.
Smoke Inn Online
Bought at Smoke Inn Online
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Dark Roast Coffee
Paired with Dark Roast Coffee
Like
Comment
Share
James T. Patterson
James T. Patterson
Smoked Feb 23
Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition
8718
87
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
A cigar I've had often, but this will be the first time in the Toro size. The profile is still full of chocolate, coffee, and a light mix of pepper / spice. The draw was just a tad tighter but remained smooth with a clean burn.
BL Luxuries
Bought at BL Luxuries
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Crown Royal Canadian Whiskey
Paired with Crown Royal Canadian Whiskey
Like
Comment
Share
James T. Patterson
James T. Patterson
Smoked Jan 24
Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition
8718
88
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Consistent review, now having 2 years of rest. The profile is full of chocolate, coffee, and a light mix of pepper & spice. The burn needed a couple touch-ups this time. Flavors stayed true without any bitterness, allowing rich tobacco tones to shine through. The draw was smooth and open.
Smoke Inn Online
Bought at Smoke Inn Online
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Coca Cola Soda
Paired with Coca Cola Soda
Like
Comment
Share
James T. Patterson
James T. Patterson
Smoked Oct 20, 2025
Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition
8718
89
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Consistent review, now after 21 months rest. The profile is full of chocolate, coffee, and a light mix of pepper & spice. The burn remained fairly even. Flavors stayed true without any bitterness, allowing rich tobacco tones to shine through. The draw was still airy and open.
Smoke Inn Online
Bought at Smoke Inn Online
Las Vegas Festival Grounds
Smoked at Las Vegas Festival Grounds
Like
Comment
Share
James T. Patterson
James T. Patterson
Smoked Oct 20, 2025
Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition
8718
89
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Consistent review, now after 21 months rest. The profile is full of chocolate, coffee, and a light mix of pepper & spice. The burn remained fairly even. Flavors stayed true without any bitterness, allowing rich tobacco tones to shine through. The draw was still airy and open.
Smoke Inn Online
Bought at Smoke Inn Online
Las Vegas Festival Grounds
Smoked at Las Vegas Festival Grounds
Like
Comment
Share
James T. Patterson
James T. Patterson
Smoked May 25, 2025
Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition
8718
90
Flavor
Draw
Burn
Appearance
Updated review after 16 months rest. This one is full of chocolate, coffee, and a light mix of pepper & spice. A slow even burn allows for a very long enjoyable smoke. Flavors stay true without any bitterness, allowing rich tobacco tones to shine through. Fantastic appearance as well. Draw is still a tad airy.
Smoke Inn Online
Bought at Smoke Inn Online
Boxpressd at Home
Smoked at Boxpressd at Home
Dr Pepper Soda
Paired with Dr Pepper Soda
Like
Comment
Share

Origin: Dominican Republic

Strength: Medium

Wrapper

  • Unknown

Binder

  • Unknown

Filler

  • Unknown
Top Flavor Notes
Ash
Citrus
Clove
Hay
Cedar / Oak

Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition Vitolas

Gordo (6"x60)
Gordo (6"x60)
Toro (6"x58)
Toro (6"x58)

Where To Buy Montecristo New York Connoisseur Edition

No product details available
New Nubs PostCreate Smoke SessionAdd to HumidorReview Shop / LoungeRate ProductAdd / Invite Friends